Every now and then the drama in Paris heats up enough to distract us from the scenery, thanks to electrically alive performances by Juliette Binoche and Romain Duris. Duris plays Pierre, a dancer whose terminal heart condition has kept him virtually captive for the past few weeks. Holed up in his [msu: cozily: ]cozily charming Parisian apartment, he watches his neighbors and daydreams about their lives, like Jimmy Stewart in Rear Window. Binoche is Pierre’s sister Elise, who moves into his apartment to take care of him until he can have the surgery that will either cure or kill him.
His illness has turned Pierre into a walking Seize the Day bulletin board, but Duris gives him a gentle intensity that makes the cliche work — even as Pierre urges family and friends to relish the good fortune of not just being alive, but living in the City of Light.Besides, it’s such a pleasure to watch Binoche’s hesitant Elise let down her guard and unleash a tsunami of warmth and joie de vivre that you don’t want to quibble about what made it happen.
Klapisch wants to give us a panoramic view of Paris through his story as well as his lens, so he crams the script with intersecting stories. But these generally fizzle out before they ever really get [msu: started: ]started, leaving us emotionally stranded. Some characters are barely on screen long enough to register as individuals, like a would-be Parisian from Cameroon who dies trying to emigrate illegally. Others — like a professor who falls for a student young enough to be his granddaughter — play out their thinly developed stories long enough to wear out their welcome.
In the end, you don’t really care about anything but Pierre, Elise, and the idealized city they love — and you don’t know them well enough to care very deeply. But they make good company for a couple of hours, and sometimes that’s all you want from a movie.
Like Paris, New York, I Love You spins several intersecting narratives at once, but it has no core story. Instead, it tells about a dozen separate and equally unengaging stories, each by a different director.
Part of a planned series of similar films set in different cities, it follows Paris, je t’aime, which had some genuinely engaging segments though it still failed to gel into a compelling whole. This one just seems like a gimmick, a circus performer trying to impress us by keeping 11 plates spinning at once.
So slight they register more as notions than as narratives, the stories are cut into pieces that are then interspersed with each other, making them seem all the more artificial. Only rarely do we get the feel of a real New York moment, like when Chris Cooper, playing an American businessman, surprises a Chinese dry cleaner and his customer by greeting them in Cantonese after they’ve used it to joke around behind his back.
Perhaps because the writers and directors are almost all from somewhere else, they tend to set their stories in iconic places (cabs, Central Park, Chinatown, more cabs, Coney Island, again with Central Park). The views are mostly clichés too, and the interactions are generally stagey and unconvincing, whether Eli Wallach and Cloris Leachman are fighting cute as a long-married couple in Brighton Beach or Julie Christie is having an incomprehensible encounter with a crippled bellhop, overplayed by Shia LaBoeuf.
New York, I Love You wastes an almost criminal amount of talent, but its real shame is in how it reduces the grit, grandeur and greatness of New York to an insipid formula.
Both rated R for language and some sexual content
Maya wrote on Nov 5, 2009 7:56 AM:
Go see 'New York, I Love You'. This is a great film. Not at all what is described: much more subtle and complex. "