Featured Brokers



Princeton Real Estate






PRINCETON: Disabled student sues university over exam time
Friday, November 6, 2009 8:32 AM EST
By Kristine Snodgrass, Staff Writer

Current Rating: 3 of 1 votes!Rate File:



   A Princeton University freshman with learning disabilities has filed a lawsuit against the university after it denied her request for extra time while taking exams.

   The Ivy League university informed student Diane E. Metcalf-Legette in September that she would not be granted 100 percent extended time, or double time, on examinations and other course assessments as she had requested, according to court documents.

   In response, her attorneys filed a civil complaint last week in the U.S. District Court of New Jersey. Brought under Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act, it seeks injunctive relief, attorneys fees, costs and other expenses.

   The day after it was filed, U.S. District Judge Anne Thompson denied a temporary restraining order on the basis the plaintiff failed to show she would suffer irreparable harm if it were not granted.

   The denial came on the day of Ms. Metcalf-Legette’s first timed midterm examination. The next court date is scheduled for Jan. 11 when a judge will decide whether a preliminary junction will be granted before fall term final exams, which begin two days later.
   University spokeswoman Emily Aronson said the lawsuit still is in its early stages, and the university will in the meantime remain committed to ensuring students with disabilities have access to its programs.

   ”We are attentive to our obligations under state and federal law to ensure equal access to our programs and activities, and we have an Office of Disability Services that helps respond to these requests on a case-by-case basis as they pertain to the specific individual needs of each member of our community,” she said in an e-mail.

   A resident of Centreville, Va., Ms. Metcalf-Legette has been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, mixed receptive expressive language disorder, disorder of written expression and developmental coordination disorder, according to the complaint.

   These disorders impact a person’s ability to comprehend and express language, recall previous material, communicate in writing and focus on work, among other difficulties.

   As a result of her mixed receptive expressive language disorder, she must read sentences four or five times before she understands it, according to the complaint. And her developmental coordination disorder affects her ability to write and organize thoughts and ideas in written compositions, according to the complaint.

   She disclosed her learning disabilities to the university during the application process and, according to university procedure, submitted her request in August to its Office of Disability Services.

   The request included documentation of her disabilities from a clinic psychologist and a recommendation for the accommodation.

   A member of the university’s intercollegiate soccer team, Ms. Metcalf-Legette received double time on her SAT and triple time for the ACT standardized test, according to the complaint. Her secondary school also granted her double time on her exams.

   In early September, the university informed her that she could receive a reduced-distraction testing environment, rest breaks, electronic texts, use of a computer and a one exam per day limit, according to the complaint. However, she was denied her request for extended exam time.

   The plaintiff’s older brother graduated from Princeton in 2008 and was granted extended time on examinations because he also had learning disabilities, according to the complaint.

   But according to the complaint, the plaintiff was informed the accommodation of extended examination time is no longer extended to any Princeton students under a policy that has been adopted across the Ivy League.

   However, this is challenged in the complaint, which asserts all other Ivy League universities, as well as the administrators of the GRE and the LSAT, will grant extended exam time in certain cases.

   Ms. Metcalf-Legette did not respond to a request for comment.

    ksnodgrass

@centraljersey.com

Central Jersey MarketPlace Ads


Get latest Local Central Jersey News from CentralJersey.com
Comments
Comments are limited to 200 words or less.

Give her a break wrote on Nov 6, 2009 6:00 PM:

" one line in this article states she needs to read something 4-5 times to get it, or respond. The college I am sure knew of this disability and it's ramifications when she was accepted at the school, surely if the rest of us read something once and can answer a question and this person needs 4-5 attempts she should be granted the extra time she seeks. "

Ignorant Eric wrote on Nov 6, 2009 4:58 PM:

" There are many disabilities that limit one's ability to communicate in a specific way, without diminishing an individual's overall intellect. A deaf or blind student may be unable to absorb or express information similarly to a hearing, seeing student, but that doesn't mean their overall contribution to an academic environment, or the overall world, isn't valuable.

To say that such a student is admitted to a prestigious university "based on sympathy," is a woefully ignorant assessment. Many of the greatest thinkers in history have had learning differences. Our advancing understanding of such differences have led to accommodations for individuals need them.

Eric, you wonder if this will affect college admission for people with disabilities. Would you worry about the same thing if a wheelchair bound person sued a university to have ramps installed when they refused? That is why people sue. Otherwise, colleges and universities could make their own rules, as Princeton asserts the Ivy Leage has. With laws to keep them in check, they are further compelled to keep admitting, and continue accommodating. "

Eric wrote on Nov 6, 2009 3:50 PM:

" First she got admitted probably based on sympathy, then she sues for not getting special treatment. I wonder if what she does really advances the cause of people with disabilities as colleges may think twice before offering admission fearing law suits and all accomodations they'd be forced to provide. "


Add your own comments:
(optional)
   


Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Although we do not have any obligation to monitor these comments, we reserve the right at all times to check the comments and to remove any information that is unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to us at our sole discretion, and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. We also reserve the right to limit future participation by any user who violates these terms. All threats to systems or site infrastructure shall be assumed genuine in nature and will be reported to the appropriate law enforcement authorities


  TOP Jobsview all
Post A Job
  TOP Homesview all
Place An Ad
  TOP Cars view all
Sell Your Car






----------------------------------Neha